Let’s not nanny British adults by censoring cartoons on beers
05 December 2018 -
FREDERICK, Maryland – Flying Dog Brewery has been defending free speech and creative expression in the United States for more than 25 years. Now, it’s taking a stand in the United Kingdom.
In May 2018, the Portman Group, a third-party organization that evaluates alcohol-related marketing, allegedly received a single complaint from a person who thought that Flying Dog’s Easy IPA Session India Pale Ale could be mistaken for a soft drink.
After months of deliberation, the Portman Group issued a final ruling, claiming that the packaging artwork “…directly or indirectly encourages illegal, irresponsible or immoderate consumption, such as binge drinking, drunkenness or drunk-driving.” It will be issuing a Retailer Alert Bulletin on 15 October, which will ask retailers not to place orders for the beer.
Notwithstanding the Portman Group’s ruling, Flying Dog has decided to continue to distribute Easy IPA in the United Kingdom.
“Not surprisingly, the alleged complaint – by a sole individual – that a product labeled ‘Easy IPA Session India Pale Ale’ might be mistaken for a soft drink was, we believe, correctly dismissed by the Portman Group,” Jim Caruso, Flying Dog CEO and cofounder of the nonprofit 1st Amendment Society, said. “That should have been the end of it. However, the Portman Group then went on to ban the creative and carefree Easy IPA label art by the internationally-renowned UK artist Ralph Steadman.”
Steadman has illustrated all of Flying Dog’s labels since 1995. In the ruling, the Portman Group claims that the artwork of this low-ABV beer “could be seen as encouraging drunkenness.”
“Without question, over-consumption, binge drinking and drunk-driving are serious health and public safety issues, and Flying Dog has always advocated for moderation and responsible social drinking,” Caruso said. “At the same time, there is no evidence to suggest that the whimsical Ralph Steadman art on the Easy IPA label causes any of those problems. We believe that British adults can think for themselves and Flying Dog, an independent U.S. craft brewer, will not honor the Portman Group’s request to discontinue shipping Easy IPA to the UK.”
The Portman Group is an organization whose signatories include Heineken, Guinness, Bacardi, Molson, Carlsberg and InBev (among others).
As James Clay, Flying Dog’s importer and UK wholesaler, are not signatories of the Portman Group, the beer will remain available in the UK market for customers to purchase as they choose.
“This is about good beer and a relatively small, artisanal U.S. craft brewery standing up against a consortium of some of the largest drinks producers in the UK,” Caruso said.
Also in support of Flying Dog is Index on Censorship, a UK-based freedom of expression organization that campaigns against censorship worldwide and runs the annual Freedom of Expression Awards. It publishes work by censored writers and artists in an award-winning quarterly magazine. Ralph Steadman illustrated the cover of its 2000 magazine “The Last Laugh.”
“Flying Dog has been a supporter of Index on Censorship for several years and we’re pleased they’re standing up to this ridiculous decision,” Index on Censorship chief executive Jodie Ginsberg said. “The idea that, based on looking at this cartoon, people might go out and drink themselves stupid is laughable. We need to treat adults like the grown-ups they are.”
About Flying Dog Brewery:
As one of the fastest-growing regional craft breweries in the United States, Flying Dog has been brewing world-class beer that pushes the confines of traditional styles for almost 25 years. Flying Dog attracts everyone from craft beer connoisseurs to those just catching the wave with up to 20 styles available at any given time. Introduced to Flying Dog by the Gonzo writer Hunter S. Thompson, artist Ralph Steadman has produced original art for Flying Dog’s labels since 1995. Named the Mid-Size Craft Brewery of the Year at the 2009 Great American Beer Festival (the highest honor for its size in the United States), recent accolades for Flying Dog include its Pale Ale ranked as the #1 American Pale Ale in the U.S. by The New York Times. For more information, visit www.flyingdogbrewery.com.